When should I rent a dumpster instead of hiring Greenway?

Rent a dumpster when you have an ongoing project that will last 8 to 30 days — a kitchen remodel, a roofing job, a slow garage cleanout you want to do over several weekends. Hire Greenway when you want the junk gone in one day with zero labor on your end. Dumpsters are for slow, self-paced loading. We're for fast, done-for-you cleanouts.

How does Greenway compare to College Hunks Hauling Junk?

College Hunks operates similarly to 1-800-Got-Junk — about more expensive than Greenway for the same job. They're also franchised. Greenway offers more flexible scheduling, bilingual (English and Spanish) service across Central Florida, and a lower minimum ( vs their typical ).

When should I NOT hire Greenway Removal?

Three situations: (1) If you have an ongoing renovation that'll produce debris over weeks, rent a dumpster — it'll be cheaper. (2) If you only have a single bag of household trash, just put it out with your curbside pickup — our minimum doesn't make sense for small trash. (3) If you have hazardous materials (paint, motor oil, pesticides), those need to go to your county household hazardous waste facility, not us. We'll tell you honestly which route is best when you call.

Do you charge tipping?

No. Greenway pays our crews a fair wage so tipping is never expected. National chains sometimes have a tipping expectation baked into the experience, which is a hidden expense most customers don't think about. What we quote is what you pay — no tipping pressure at the end.

Are all Central Florida junk removal companies the same?

No. Local independents like Greenway are typically 15 to 30% cheaper than national chains for the same job. Pickup-truck operators you find on Facebook Marketplace are sometimes cheaper still, but they're usually uninsured, don't give receipts, and sometimes dump illegally — which can land the property owner in legal trouble if the items are traced back to your address.

Home › Compare

Greenway vs 1-800-Got-Junk vs College Hunks vs Dumpster Rental — Honest Comparison

Q: Is Greenway cheaper than 1-800-Got-Junk?

Yes, typically 25 to 40% cheaper for the same volume of junk. We're a locally owned Central Florida crew with no franchise royalties or national TV advertising costs. A 1/2 truckload that costs to through 1-800-Got-Junk runs to with Greenway.

We're not going to pretend Greenway is the right choice for every situation — that's a sales pitch, not honest advice. For one-day cleanouts in Central Florida, we're almost always 15-30% cheaper than national chains and faster than renting a dumpster. But for multi-week renovation projects, a dumpster wins. For a single bag of trash, curbside pickup wins. Here's the full honest side-by-side, including the situations where you should not hire us. Call (321) 257-2413 and we'll tell you which option actually fits your job.

The full comparison table

Here's how Greenway stacks up against the two biggest national chains and the dumpster-rental alternative on every factor that matters when you're picking a junk removal option in Central Florida.

Full 2026 service is on our , including single-item rates and cleanout-by-type breakdowns.

Greenway vs dumpster rental: which is actually cheaper?

This is the #1 comparison question we get. The honest answer depends on one thing: how long will your project take?

When a dumpster wins

Rent a dumpster when the project will last 8 to 30 days — a kitchen remodel, a roof tear-off, a methodical multi-weekend garage cleanout where you're going to sort stuff as you go. A 10-yard dumpster in Central Florida runs to for a 7-day rental, and you can load it at your own pace. If you're doing a 3-week renovation, that's a dumpster situation.

When Greenway wins

Hire us when you want it gone in one day with zero labor on your end. Our 15-yard truckload matches the capacity of a 10-yard dumpster — but you don't lift anything, you don't deal with the rental company, and it's done in 60-90 minutes. For estate cleanouts, evictions, apartment move-outs, or any "just get it out of my life today" situation, we win on time-saved.

Hidden dumpster expenses most people miss: permit fees in Kissimmee and some Orlando neighborhoods, driveway damage risk (a loaded dumpster can crack asphalt), overage fees if you fill past the lip, daily rental fees after day 7, and the time you lose spending 3 weekends loading it yourself. Add those up and a "cheap" dumpster often ends up more expensive than hiring us.

1-800-Got-Junk is a national franchise. That means every local operation pays franchise royalties (typically 7-10% of gross revenue), national ad fund fees (another 2-3%), plus the corporate overhead baked into every quote. Their TV and digital ad budget is enormous — and it's funded by the prices they charge on every job. That's 10-15% of your bill going to things that don't touch your driveway.

Greenway is locally owned, operated out of Groveland, FL, and we don't franchise. We pay for the truck, the gas, the insurance, the dump fees, and the crew. That's why we're more affordable for the same work. We also don't have a national call center — when you call (321) 257-2413, you're talking to the owner or a team member who knows your address and your crew.

Where 1-800-Got-Junk wins: bigger brand recognition and a slightly more polished online booking flow. If those things matter more than saving -200 per job, they're a fine choice.

Greenway vs College Hunks: what's the difference?

College Hunks Hauling Junk is also a national franchise, and their approach is similar to 1-800-Got-Junk — typically higher than Greenway for the same truck volume. Their brand angle is "young, energetic crews" and they do a good job with the front-of-house experience. They also bundle junk removal with moving services, which we do too (see our moving services page).

Where Greenway has the edge:

Lower minimum ( vs their ~) — better for single-item pickups.
Bilingual (English + Spanish) service across Central Florida — they don't advertise this.
Lower overall expense for the same volume.
More flexible scheduling — we're smaller and can often squeeze in a same-day job where they can't.
Combined junk + cleaning packages for move-outs and pre-listings.

Where College Hunks has the edge: slightly more polished uniforms and a bigger brand footprint if that matters to you.

When should you NOT hire Greenway?

Being honest here because it builds trust and because nobody wins if we take a job that doesn't fit. Here are the three situations where you should skip Greenway:

1. You have a multi-week renovation

If your project will produce debris over 2+ weeks — kitchen remodel, roof replacement, whole-room gut — rent a dumpster. You'll pay less in total and you won't be scheduling multiple pickups.

2. You only have one or two bags of household trash

Our minimum is for a reason — it covers drive time, a 2-person crew, and disposal. If you just have a couple of bags, your weekly curbside pickup is included in your garbage bill already. Use it. We'll still be here when the real cleanout comes.

3. You have hazardous materials

Paint, motor oil, gasoline, pesticides, antifreeze, propane tanks, asbestos, ammunition — none of those can legally go in our truck. Orange County and Osceola County both run free Household Hazardous Waste drop-off programs. See our what we take page for the full list of what goes where.

Bottom line: when you call us, we'll tell you honestly if your situation is better served by a dumpster, a curbside pickup, or a free county program. We'd rather send you to the right answer and earn your call the next time than push you into the wrong service now.

Have a one-day cleanout?

Call us and we'll quote it in two minutes — honest advice on whether we're the right fit.

Call (321) 257-2413 Get Free Quote

Comparison FAQs

Is Greenway cheaper than 1-800-Got-Junk?

Yes, 25-40% cheaper for the same volume because we're locally owned with no franchise royalties.

When should I rent a dumpster instead?

When your project will last 2+ weeks. Dumpsters are for slow self-paced loading. We're for fast done-for-you cleanouts.

How does Greenway compare to College Hunks?

20-30% cheaper, lower minimum ( vs ), bilingual service, more flexible scheduling.

When should I NOT hire Greenway?

Multi-week renovations (rent a dumpster), 1-2 trash bags (use curbside pickup), hazardous materials (use county HHW).

Do Central Florida junk companies charge tips?

We don't. National chains often have tipping expectations baked in. We pay our crews fair wages.

No. Local independents like us are 15-30% cheaper than national chains. Pickup-truck operators on Facebook are sometimes cheaper but often uninsured and sometimes dump illegally.